Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Star Trek Legends Gates McFadden & Tawny Newsome Unpack Generations of Galactic Grievances & Triumphs
The Roddenberry Foundation’s Trek Talks 2026 recently hosted a truly stellar panel, beaming up two Star Trek titans from different eras: Gates McFadden, the iconic Dr. Beverly Crusher from Star Trek: The Next Generation, Picard, and Prodigy, and the dynamic Tawny Newsome, known as Beckett Mariner from Star Trek: Lower Decks. Newsome also wielded a scriptwriter’s pen (and prosthetics for Illa Dax) on the upcoming Starfleet Academy. Their candid conversation peeled back layers on everything from iconic episodes to the fight for creative control in the vast Star Trek universe.
A highlight of the digital event was a deep dive into Starfleet Academy’s first season, specifically episode five, “Series Acclimation Mil.” Co-written by Tawny Newsome and Kirsten Beyer, this pivotal chapter sees SAM (Kerrice Brooks) investigating the mysterious disappearance of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine’s beloved Emissary, Benjamin Sisko, portrayed by Avery Brooks. Newsome passionately revealed how she championed making it a Sisko-centric narrative, fighting to give DS9 the modern Star Trek attention it deserves.
Tawny’s dedication to Starfleet Academy was immense, even if her second season involvement was reduced due to other commitments. She had a sprawling 72-page initial draft for the Sisko episode, trimmed to a lean 48. Newsome also fulfilled her own Star Trek dreams playing Illa Dax, the 32nd-century host of the Dax symbiont, complete with impressive Cardassian and Bajoran prosthetics. She shared that her contributions in Season 1 felt like winning the lottery, honouring beloved characters.
Cirroc Lofton, reprising his role as Jake Sisko, became the sole Deep Space Nine actor to return to the franchise in this new series. It was a powerful, full-circle moment for fans of the enduring legacy of Benjamin Sisko and his family. The series unfortunately concludes after its second season, leaving many of Newsome’s exciting ideas for SAM and new species unexplored.
The panel truly underscored the vast differences in creative freedom between Star Trek generations. Tawny Newsome was deeply embedded in the Starfleet Academy writers’ room, actively shaping characters like SAM. Gates McFadden, conversely, shared her struggles navigating the male-dominated sets of Star Trek: The Next Generation in the 80s and 90s.
McFadden famously recounted being dismissed from TNG’s first season for daring to question scripts she found sexist or racist. Her creative input was often relegated to covert suggestions via Patrick Stewart. Even on Star Trek: Picard, her ideas were sometimes cut during production, a testament to the persistent challenges women faced in the industry.
However, Dr. Crusher did get her moments. McFadden shared two instances of direct creative contributions: crafting clown scenes for “The Big Goodbye” and choreographing the memorable tap dance in “Data’s Day,” even suggesting some dialogue tweaks. These small victories highlight a persistent fight for agency within the Star Trek machine.
Then there’s “Sub Rosa,” the infamous TNG episode Gates McFadden initially thought was a disaster, a sentiment shared by Patrick Stewart. Today, she’s learned to embrace its delightful absurdity, especially Crusher’s unforgettable “green-eyed orgasm.” Tawny Newsome lauded McFadden’s performance, noting how playing it straight made the episode a hilarious, cult classic.
Starfleet Academy season one is currently streaming on Paramount+, with the second and final season’s premiere date yet to be announced.
The Nerd Bureau Take: This Trek Talks panel was a masterclass in Star Trek history, revealing the hidden battles fought behind the scenes. From Tawny Newsome’s passionate advocacy for Benjamin Sisko to Gates McFadden’s trailblazing fight against sexism, it’s clear that the spirit of exploration and pushing boundaries extends beyond the final frontier and into the very creation of these beloved stories. It’s a powerful reminder that every iconic Star Trek moment has a story behind it.
